Expert says navigation skills may soon be lost on sat-nav generation

Many of us are getting more and more reliant on our sat-nav devices. But are they causing more harm than good?

It’s not just the publishers of paper maps who have cause to rue the rise of the sat-navs, a navigation expert suggests.

Roger McKinlay says we’ve become so dependent on our smart devices to get from A to B that we may lose our in-built navigation skills.

He even indicates that the seemingly unstoppable march towards driverless cars may not necessarily be a good thing.

McKinlay reckons that the next generation of motorists should be taught map reading and navigation in the classroom… before it’s too late.

And he should know. McKinlay is not only the Royal Institute of Navigation’s former president, he is now a consultant in satellite communication.

He believes if we don’t return to using our natural compass soon, we’re in grave danger of losing it once and for all.


Humans 1 Machines 0?
McKinlay believes our increasing reliance on computer assistance could prove an expensive own goal for the human race.

This is especially as he claims navigation technology isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.

He says people may dream about a future of drones and driverless cars delivering our shopping to our homes.

But he says sat-navs can:

  • Offer wrong information once signals are bounced around indoors or in a crowded environment
  • Make our map-reading skills worse. Simulator drivers following sat-nav orders find it harder to ascertain where they have been travelling than map users
  • Make it difficult for users to know if they have passed the same destination twice

McKinlay adds that rescue crews in mountain areas grow weary of looking for lost people who have drained the battery in their smartphone.


But isn’t McKinlay fighting a losing battle?
Experts claim that four in five people will have smartphones by the start of the next decade.

An increased and upgraded satellite network should improve sat-nav capability. The US alone spends $1 billion (£694 million) on maintaining GPS satellites every year in addition to the more than $10 billion (£6.94 billion) to put them in place.

Yet McKinlay says navigation is not just knowing where you are, which is why he thinks we must start using our directional skills once more.


Could schools be the answer?
McKinlay passionately believes that map reading and navigation should be taught in schools as skills for life.

He makes a comparison with calculators and computers. These have not taken away our need to know all about numbers, he says. So why should we allow sat-navs to take away our directional sense?

McKinlay’s calls could now encourage the increasingly tech-dependent human race to start re-claiming their brains.


  1. medicijnen zonder recept: Veilig online bestellen sandoz
    Chiavari Medikamente in der Schweiz kaufen

  2. médicaments disponible en ligne avec livraison rapide Nepenthes Bassersdorf Medikamente
    ohne Rezept

  3. Spot on with this write-up, I really believe this website needs much more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the info!

  4. medicamentos disponible en farmacia de Brasil RIA Landeck médicaments :
    astuces pour une recherche efficace en ligne

  5. Hello! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and tell you I genuinely enjoy reading your articles. Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the same topics? Thanks a ton!

  6. vente en ligne de médicaments en France galpharm Settimo Torinese Prix compétitif pour la médicaments

  7. whoah this blog is fantastic i really like studying your posts. Stay up the great work! You already know, many persons are searching around for this info, you could aid them greatly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *